What to play next
Games like Pony Island
Pony Island (2016) by Daniel Mullins Games is a Puzzle · Simulator · Adventure game. If it clicked for you, these 12 games share genres and play-style signals worth comparing. Connect your Steam library for picks based on your own playtime, ratings, and backlog.
12 games similar to Pony Island
Make it personal.
PlusOnePlay ranks games you already own using your playtime, ratings, mood, and preferred game length—and explains every pick.
Rank my Steam library